Bouncer vs Swing: Best Bouncers And Swings Reviewed

Last Updated on

Many of us would hold our babies 24/7 if we could. Still, we have to put them down to shower, cook, and occasionally, rest. Having a bouncer or swing available will keep your baby calm and free your arms and hands to do other things.

To be honest, as a new dad, a year ago I didn't even know, these things existed. We bought a standard bouncer for our boy, and a friend gave us their old swing. So we a chance to test both of them. Keep reading to find out the winner between bouncer vs swing.

Key Points For Busy Parents

Four Great Options To Calm Your Baby

Baby bouncers and swings have a magical effect on babies. They are excellent tools for soothing a fussy infant or keeping your little one occupied while you get things done. Swings and bouncers have a reclining position and offer the same comforting motion of rocking as in a parent's arms. 

I: Standard Bouncer

This no-frills option requires an adult to move the seat up and down manually. It also bounces in response to your baby's kicks and wiggles.

A father with his two children in a room, the baby is in a bouncer

It's perfect for when you need to work out, meditate or perform yoga. You can place the baby on the floor next to you as you take a little time to de-stress. 

II: Electric Bouncer

This type of seat requires a battery or electricity. Some units feature a vibration mode, resembling the soft hum of riding in a car. It may also include toys that suspend from a bar for interactive play. 

III: Swing

Baby In A Swing And A Dog Is Keeping Watch

Motorized swings operate on batteries or an AC adapter. There are full-size and portable sizes available.

With this containment device, you simply choose a setting. After that, the swing will rock your baby back and forth, or side to side until he or she falls asleep.

A swing is ideal for times when you are exhausted, but your baby is not.

IV: Bouncer/Swing Combo

For those who can't decide between a bouncer or a swing, this dual option may offer the best of both worlds. The seat detaches from the swing and converts to a bouncer.

I don't like buying these combo products, as they generally don't do two things equally well and you have to make compromises. That said, if you are searching for one, then a Graco DuetConnect may be your best choice.

Standard Bouncer vs Swing: What's The Difference?

Weight & Portability

Bouncers are lightweight and portable. Assembly is effortless, and most models fold easily for storage. 

Light-weight bouncer Babybjorb

For example, in the picture, you can see a folded BabyBjörn (check the latest price on Amazon) bouncer. I've also written a proper BabyBjorn bouncer review, check it out if you wish.

In contrast, swings can be bulky. Depending on the dimensions, it may be difficult to fit through a door or narrow hallway. It was more convenient for me to set the swing up in the living room and leave it there. This way, we could fold clothes, watch TV and eat while my baby boy enjoyed the gentle motion of the swing.

You also need more storage space for a swing. We gave ours to a friend after our baby was too old for it. But we still have our bouncer somewhere in the closet.

Longevity of use

A bouncer sits low to the ground. Most models can hold a baby up to six months old.

Since swings are heftier than bouncers, they tend to hold more weight. Some parents report using the containment device for up to a year.

That said, in my personal experience a swing becomes more quickly absolute. When our 20-pound baby wiggled to look around, the swing became uncomfortably wobbly.

Other Features

Most swings feature music, a vibration mode, or toys to relax babies and keep them occupied. Many settings will give you ample alternatives to keep your baby rested.  

In contrast, many bouncers don't have a lot of extra features.

For example, we had to buy a toy for a BabyBjörn bouncer as it's not included in the package.

General Advice

Some things are essential for bouncers and swings alike.

Restraints

This feature is important regardless if you choose a bouncer or a swing. The harness will keep infants from falling out of the seat.

Many swings use a 5-point-harness because the device may become unstable if your little one is very active. A baby bouncer, in contrast, is meant to be moved by your baby, so it usually comes with a 3-point-harness that allows more mobility.

Removable or Waterproof Covers

In the event of an accidental leak or mess, waterproof seats wipe down easily. You may also prefer a cover that detaches from the frame so that you can throw it in the washer.


Bouncer vs Swing: Which One Should I Choose?


Baby's Temperament

Your baby is the most important influencer of your choice. So you have to consider his or her temperament. There's no point buying a swing nor a bouncer unless it can calm your baby.

For example, our baby started crying when we weren't sitting just next to him. It neglected the benefits of having a swing that you don't have to bounce yourself.

Space

Your choice will also depend on how much space you have available in your nursery. A bouncer is the best pick if you don't have much storage space or you travel a lot.

Bouncer vs Swing infographic- you have to consider baby's nature, your lifestyle, baby's mood, space, money, pets

For example, we often visit friends and family. As BabyBjörn bouncer is light-weight and very easy to fold, it made our life more comfortable. It also saved my nerves as I'm the one who has to drag all the baby stuff to a car and later unpack the stuff. I think the BabyBjörn bouncer is a very dad-friendly product.

Baby's Mood

On the other hand, swings offer more features. Depending on your baby, it may calm him better than a bouncer. Some parents have been able to use swings a longer time, but as I've explained, that's not my experience.

Pets

A swing is also a better option if you have small pets in the house. They generally sit higher off the ground than bouncers. So dogs and cats can not so easily disturb your baby during naps.

Still, if you can't decide, you have the option of buying a combo set.

Are Baby Bouncers And Swings Safe?

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), bouncers and swings are safe as long as parents don't keep their babies there too long. They should not be used for routine sleep.

To minimize risks, experts suggest:

  • Read the safety guidelines that come with the unit
  • Place bouncy seats on the floor. Resist the temptation to elevate them to a countertop, table, desk, sofa or bed
  • Always secure your child in the seat with restraints and check to make sure that provide a snug fit
  • check
    Keep the baby within eyesight at all times. Even if you have to use the bathroom, you can sit a bouncy seat on the floor
  • check
    Move the baby to a crib once they fall asleep
  • check
    Stop using the containment device when your baby reaches the manufacturer's recommended limit or can sit up on her own
  • check
    Look for items with a Juvenile Products Manufacturer's Association (JPMA) label to ensure the bouncer or swing was tested and meets safety standards

Three Best Bouncers For DadProgress Reviewed

BabyBjörn Bouncer Balance Soft(Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 20lb when you are using it as a bouncer. You can also use it as a chair and then the weight limit is 29lb

Item Weight: 4.6lb

Standard Bouncer

PROS

CONS

  • BabyBjörn bouncer is very lightweight, so it's easy to transport around the house or take with you while traveling
  • It's stable
  • The ergonomic design means that the weight of your baby is distributed evenly
  • There are six different colors available (don't buy black though as dust is clearly visible on it)
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    There are two materials available. You can choose between cotton and mesh
  • This bouncer is safe. It's JPMA certified and belongs to Oeko-Tex Class I
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    There are three different positions available depending on your baby's weight 
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat bad is machine-washable
  • The price is quite high. For that price, they could have at least included the toy bar (you have to buy it separately by the way). That said, I had this bouncer and never regretted buying it

Fisher-Price Baby Bouncer (Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 20lb 

Item Weight: 5.8lb

Electric Bouncer: It's a standard bouncer (so the movements are triggered by you or your baby), but it also has an option to switch on the calming vibrations

PROS

CONS

  • This Fisher-Price bouncer is competitively priced. The removable toy bar with two toys is included in the package
  • It's also a stable bouncer
  • There are two different colors available 
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat bad is machine-washable 
  • This bouncer is little bigger than the BabyBjörn bouncer s
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    Batteries are not included
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    This bouncer isn't adjustable

Fisher-Price Moonlight Meadow Deluxe Bouncer (Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 25lb 

Item Weight: 7.7lb

Electric Bouncer: It's a standard bouncer (so the movements are triggered by you or your baby), but it also has an option to switch on the calming vibrations. This bouncer also plays calming music for your child

PROS

CONS

  • The insert of this bouncer is soft and cozy. If your baby doesn't already feel relaxed enough, you can turn on some soft music
  • The toy bar is included in the package
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    It's a stable bouncer
  • There are three different colors available 
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat pad and insert are machine-washable 
  • This bouncer is bigger than the BabyBjörn bouncer. So it may not be the best choice if you have to travel a lot
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    Batteries are sold separately
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    This bouncer isn't adjustable

Three Best Swings For DadProgress Reviewed

Graco Slim Spaces Compact Baby Swing (Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 25lb

Item Weight: 13.5lb

Baby Swing: This baby swing is battery operated

PROS

CONS

  • The legs of this swing are adjustable and it's also easy to fold. So this is a perfect baby swing if you have to travel a lot 
  • The toy bar is included in the package
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    It's a stable swing
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat pad and insert are machine-washable 
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    There are only two different colors available
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    You have to buy the batteries separately
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    The two hanging toys are quite boring for most babies

Fisher-Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle And Swing (Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 25lb 

Item Weight: 24.9lb

Baby Swing: This swing is operated by batteries or plug in

PROS

CONS

  • There are two ways to swing, two recline positions and six different swing speeds. So this swing allows you to find what really soothes your baby
  • The toys are included in the package
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    You don't need batteries, just plug it in
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat pad and insert are machine-washable
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    The swinging motion is surprisingly slow
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    This swing is quite heavy compared to some others baby swings
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    Many parents have had problems with swing legs. They don't touch the floor at the same time, and so the swing is unstable

Graco Dreamglider Gliding Swing And Sleeper (Check The Latest Price On Amazon)

Weight limit: Up To 30lb

Item Weight: 22.2lb

Baby Swing: This swing is operated by batteries or plug in

PROS

CONS

  • The longevity of use is great because the weight-limit is 30lb and this swing doubles as a sleeper. The seat easily recliner into a sleeper
  • You can switch calming vibrations, there are two speed setting
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    This swing has six gliding speeds
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The toys are included in the package
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    You don't need batteries, just plug it in
  • Alternate Arrow Up
    The seat pad and insert are machine-washable
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    Many parents have had problems with noise when using this swing at higher speeds
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    Graco Dreamglider plays music, but the sound quality is terrible
  • Alternate Arrow Down
    The seat doesn't recline completely flat

To Sum It Up

It may be hard to decide between a baby bouncer and a swing. You could buy both of them, of course. But if you don’t want to buy stuff that you may not need, it’s a good idea to think about the pros and cons of both of them. I hope this guide will help you to decide.

Should you buy the best baby swing or bouncer for your newborn? They are different, but maybe you don’t need to buy both of them. Click to read my guide to learn the pros and cons